A Few Thoughts on the Horror Genre

Quotes

"We will always probe nothingness and mystery with our imagination; the result will be among other things horror. The tide will rise with the black beauty and perfection of the hag/s characterization an dark wisdom, and the teachings of the vampire's hopeless immortality. As the perfect love story tickles our fancy, perfect horror taunts our fears. Both inspire to new heights and depths. And the human psyche is dimensionless." ~ Fiona

"The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown." ~ H. P. Lovecraft

"This predilection for art that promises we will be frightened by it, shaken by it, at times repulsed by it seems to be as deeply imprinted in the human psyche as the counter-impulse toward daylight, rationality, scientific skepticism, truth and the "real." ... And this is the forbidden truth, the unspeakable taboo--that evil is not always repellent but frequently attractive; that it has the power to make of us not simply victims, as nature and accident do, but active accomplices." ~ Joyce Carol Oates

"Like sex, horror is seductive - enticing the reader to accept the forbidden; allowing a fascination with the carnal, the forbidden; titillating the mind as sex does both the mind and sense. Reading horror is an act of consensual masochism: you willingly submit to the pleasures of fear - scare me! Please?" ~ Paula Guran

"Sturgeons Law--which states that ninety percent of everything is crap--needs to be revised to be applicable to the horror genre; the percentage has to be raised." ~ Dean Koontz

"...Many of the feelings that typically attend being horrified are intrinsically unpleasant; for they include gagging, nausea, choking, stomach churning, tenseness, a creepy or crawling sensation, felt in the flesh, and so on."~ Noel Carroll

"If you want to be a writer, don't write horror whatever you do. Call it suspense, or dark fantasy, or anything but horror. Supernatural horror and hard-core splatterpunk are on their way out--unless it involves vampires." ~ Tom Beber

"Can there be something tonic about pure active fear in these times of passive, confused oppression? It is nice to choose to be frightened, when one need not be." ~ Elizabeth Bowen

"The problem is that horror is not a genre, it is an emotion. Horror is not a kind of fiction. It's a progressive form of fiction that continually evolves to meet the fears and anxieties of its times." ~ Douglas E. Winter

"I am conscious of writing in a tradition that blurs the boundaries between three fantastic genres: supernatural horror, fantasy and science fiction. I have always been of the opinion that you can't make firm distinctions between the three." ~ China Mieville

A Few WWW Sources

Buried.com is another reasonably comprehensive site with reviews, interviews, and a list of links.

The Cabinet of Dr. Casey: The Horror Web Page is reasonably comprehensive, covering horror in several different media. .

Dark Echo Horror is deep and rich. It includes interviews, articles, essays, reviews, and a good link collection.

Fiona's Fear and Loathing site is a good source for book reviews.

Gothic.net is a useful and quite comprehensive site. Good collection of reviews.

Horrorfind is horror search engine that covers about 6,000 sites covering all aspect of horror.

The Horror Writer's Association includes Stoker Award winners, excerpts from new novels, a reading list, and related websites. Some sections are only available to members.

The International Horror Guild has awards for notable novels.

Necropsy: the Review of Horror Fiction is an e-zine housed at LSU and published quarterly. June Pulliam, the Editor, is also known for her Hooked on Horror mentioned below.

Tabula Rasa includes quite a good history of the genre.

A Few Other Sources

Fantasy and Horror: A Critical and Historical Guide to Literature, Illustration, Film, TV, Radio, and the Internet is a selective critical guide that covers the genre from 1762.

Gothic Writers: A Critical and Bibliographic Guide edited by Douglass H. Thomson. Reasonably detailed coverage of 50 authors (from 1762 - 1999) with a list of major works, an analytical essay, and a bibliography of selected criticism. There is also a general bibliography of sources.

Hooked on Horror: A Guide to Reading Interests in Horror Fiction by Anthony Fonseca and June Pulliam is another in the Genreflecting series. An essential purchase for the reader advisor, especially since horror is the genre that most librarians are unfamiliar with. Descriptive rather than evaluative. The first edition overs titles in print from 1994 to 1998 and the second edition covers titles from 1998 to 2002. Chapters are organized by sub genres.

Horror of the 20th Century: An Illustrated History by Robert Weinberg.

Horror Readers' Advisory: the Librarian's Guide to Vampires, Killer Tomatoes, and Haunted Houses provides a good current overview.

The Penguin Encyclopedia of Horror and the Supernatural.

The St. James Guide to Horror, Ghost, and Gothic Writers edited by David Pringle is similar to their other genre writer guides in its biobibilographical approach. Should be in most collections.

St. Martin's issues the Year's Best Fantasy and Horror series that is now in its 17th volume. Half of the stories are horror. This is an excellent way to become familiar with new and noteworthy authors.

Supernatural Fiction Writers: Fantasy and Horror by Everett Bleiler is now quite dated but does a good job for the classics through the 1960s.

Weird Tales is the benchmark periodical.

Definitions

Horror fiction has these common elements:

The key ingredient in horror fiction is its ability to provoke fear or terror in readers, usually via something demonic.. There should be a sense of dread, unease, anxiety, or foreboding. Some critics have noted that experiencing horror fiction is like reading about your worst nightmares.

There is some debate as to whether "horror" is a genre or, like "adventure" an aspect that may be found in several genres. Horror is a certain mood or atmosphere that might be found in a variety of places. Traditionally, horror was associated with certain archtypes such as demons, witches, ghosts, vampires and the like. However, this can be found in other genres, especially fantasy. If horror is a genre, then it deals with a protagonist dealing with overwhelming dark and evil forces.

ANCIENT EVIL
Stories where ancient evil, often hidden for centuries, awakes and threatens civilization. Lovecraft is a notable author.
BLACK MAGIC
Magic used for evil purposes. SORCERY is almost always black magic. WITCHCRAFT is often evil but is sometimes good. WHITE MAGIC is magic used for good ends. Some authors use Magic for good and SORCERY for evil.
CONTEMPORARY HORROR
Horror stories set in contemporary time and in places familiar to the ordinary reader. Stephen King is the best known author. Violence is not usually unusually graphic in its description.
DARK SUSPENSE
Like DARK FANTASY or DARK FICTION, this is an alternative name for horror. However, DARK SUSPENSE relies more on terror, often psychological terror.
EROTIC HORROR
Horror stories with considerable explicit sexual activity, including violent sex. SEXUAL HORROR is an alternative label. May verge on the pornographic. Pulp periodicals combined "blood and bosoms." Sex and death have often been related; this is especially true today with AIDS. Clive Barker is a well regarded author in this sub genre. This combination can create censorship problems for the library.
GHOST STORIES
Stories where the spirits of the dead intervene in some way. Ghosts may be either good or evil. Ghosts often live in a HAUNTED PLACE which may be a house, castle, or sometimes just a place like a bridge or a garden.
GOTHIC HORROR
GOTHIC is sometimes used instead of HORROR. As Grolier says, "The earliest Gothic romance, a class of novel dealing in the mysterious and supernatural, which emerged shortly after the establishment of the novel form itself, was Horace Walpole's Castle of Otranto (1764). Reacting against the literalism and confined domesticity of Samuel Richardson, Walpole indulged a contemporary taste for the "Gothic," which for the 18th-century reader conjured up a medieval world of barbarous passions enacted in picturesque melodramatic settings of ruined castles, ancient monasteries, and wild landscapes. Within a plot designed for suspense, a delicate feminine sensibility is subjected to the onslaught of elemental forces of good and evil. Sanity and chastity are constantly threatened, and over all looms the suggestion that evil and irrationality will destroy civilization."
HAUNTED HOUSES
Places haunted by ghosts, spirits, and demons are a popular sub genre. Stories are often less graphic and more psychological. GRAVEYARDS are another popular sub-genre.
HISTORICAL HORROR
Horror stories set in the past using reasonably realistic settings. For example, a vampire story might be set in the early days of the Roman Republic.
HORROR MYSTERIES
Mystery stories with a strong horror element. For example, the detective may be a werewolf or ghosts may help to solve the crime.
HORROR SAGA
Horror stories that follow several generations of doomed or evil families. V.C. Andrews is a good example.
LITERARY HORROR
Sometimes also called DARK MAINSTREAM. Usually this is a horror story that is better written and is considered part of mainstream or general fiction. Such stories may be slower paced and less action-oriented with more emphasis on character development and metaphysical problems.
NATURE HORROR
Stories in which other living things become evil or attack humans. Examples might include microbes, rats, birds, or killer plants.
OCCULT
Refers to a variety of "non-rational" pursuits including witchcraft, astrology, tarot,and palmistry. Often used as a summary phrase for things SUPERNATURAL. Assumption that there is a world beyond our own that certain people can contact.
POSSESSION
Stories in which a character is taken over or controlled by another. That other might be a demon, some other evil force, or another human.
PSYCHOLOGICAL HORROR
Stories that rely on the psychological problems of the characters to generate horror rather than the use of external supernatural elements.
SMALL TOWN HORROR
Stories set in a small community. The contrast between the horror and the small town connotations creates a substantial tension. Stephen King has done well here.
SPLATTERPUNK
Horror stories with unusual and explicit sex and violence. Potential censorship problems.
STEALTH HORROR
Milder forms of horror issues as SUPERNATURAL FICTION, FANTASY, THRILLER. The notion is that the horror novel will find more audience under a different label.
SUPERNATURAL FICTION may be mild horror or may be LITERARY HORROR.
THREATENED CHILD
Story in which an innocent child is threatened by evil. The contrast between the child's innocence and inherent good and evil creates considerable tension. The opposite situation would be the EVIL CHILD story where the child is not innocent or good.
VAMPIRE
Creatures, often human, who have some supernatural powers and suck blood from their victims. In recent years, vampire fiction has become quite popular. Anne Rice is a good example of a popular author.
WERE CREATURES
Creatures, often wolves, who are shape shifters changing from person to animal when certain stimulus is present.
WITCHES
Characters who practice magic. Normally, WITCHES are female and WARLOCKS or MAGICIANS are male but that is not always the case.

Very Brief History

While horror stories are well rooted in myth and legend, particularly in some of the fairy tales collected in the 19th Century, Edgar Allen Poe's Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque published in 1840 was a notable landmark. Even earlier was Horace Walpole's The Castle of Otranto in 1765. Ghost stories were popular in the early 20th Century. M.R. James is an example. Lovecraft added his unique blend of fantasy and horror in the 1930s. Rosemary's Baby, probably the film more than the book, made horror popular. Stephen King soon followed with a series of increasingly popular novels and horror fiction boomed and has become the "benchmark" author. R.L. Stine's "Goosebumps" series made mild horror popular with children and younger teens. The 1970s and 1980s were a boom time for horror. Interest receded in the 1990s and publishers reduced their horror lists. In the last few years, horror has become more popular and publishing output has increased.

While horror fiction has been placed in a marginalized position within genre fiction which is itself marginalized from "real" literature, horror has long been part of real literature. Beowulf is a good example.

Awards

The most notable horror fiction awards are the Bram Stoker Awards given by the members of the Horror Writers Association. Award winners should be included in larger library collections.

Ten Must Reads from Robert Weinberg

The three most visible authors are:
  1. Stephen King
  2. Dean Koontz
  3. Anne Rice

Appeal

Introduction

John C. Glen says that he reads horror:

  1. To discover the possibility of something creepy within myself
  2. To discover the possibility of something creepy about my perfectly normal-looking neighbors
  3. To tantalize my suspicion that the world can't possibly be as orderly as it's advertised to be...
  4. To discover an external cognate (in the imagination of the author) to what I think of as my own dark secrets...
  5. For plain old-fashioned entertainment and escapism

Fundamental Fears

Fear is universal. Some people are afraid of the dark. Others dream of being swept away by giant tidal waves. With fear such an integral part of our daily existence, horror stories are not as distant as they might seem.

Some argue that horror readers read to get control over the things that scare them. We face fears and overcome via horror fiction. We can safely experience terrible things with no ill effects [we hope].

Too, there is considerable evidence that people enjoy being scared. Amusement rides are often popular because they do scare and cause people to scream.

Curiosity

Related to the fear mentioned above, most people are curious or even fascinated by horrible events and horror itself. The amazing popularity of the Goosebumps (more than 160 million copies in print) series by R.L Stine indicates that fascination with horror begins at a relatively young age. There is considerable suspense in most horror stories. Horror fiction allows the reader to explore subconscious fears and some conscious ones too.

Myth and Legend

Many of the myths and legends associated with various cultures feature stories of supernatural creatures. Greek mythology is a good example in our own culture. There is a long tradition of such stories and the belief by many that events don't just happen but that something is responsible. Supernatural events and creatures are often encountered in myth, legend, and folklore.

Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (1818) and Bram Stoker's Dracula (1897) have become legends of their own.

What Would I do?

Some people enjoy imagining what they would do if they were placed in a situation similar to that of the main character in the work. Horror stories often depict "ordinary people dealing with extraordinary threats. They like to imagine, what would I do if a dark shadow with glowing red eyes appeared in my bedroom at night?

Excitement

Horror is rarely boring. It often has an immediate emotional response. Horror appeals more to the emotions than to the intellect. The setting of most horror stories creates an environment that is very special; it creates a special sensation. Ordinarily life is mundane while horror fiction involves us with the unexpected and the unnatural.

Rejection

Since horror fiction is often rejected by many adults that may make it more appealing to some readers who see it as a literature of protest and one that challenges ordinary conventions and normality. Horror fiction then is a forbidden attraction. This may be why many teens are drawn to horror fiction and films.

Atmosphere

The dark, brooding, threatening atmosphere becomes the main character in many horror stories. Thus, mood and setting are as or more important than plot and characters. The atmosphere is often portrayed in considerable detail so it become alive and immediately threatening.

Sub Genres

As is true of other genres, many horror readers will prefer to read in a sub genre such as vampires or ghosts. The ability to identify works by type of horror is important.

Trends and Problems

Boom and Bust

As is true of some of the other genres, horror fiction seems to go through boom and bust cycles. The boom in the mid 1980s was followed by a bust and publishers substantially reduced their new works. In the boom period, publishers issued too many poorly written and derivative works. We are currently experiencing a mild boom

Horror fiction is not as popular as the other genres so there is less demand for it in libraries and book stores.

Film

As is true of the western genre, horror has been greatly influenced by film. Successful films create renewed interest in the genre and vice versa. Good example might be the 1968 film "Night of the Living Dead" and "Carrie" in 1974.

Where To Put It

Book stores and libraries are often uncertain where to place horror fiction. It is usually not segregated as are mysteries, SF/fantasy, and romance. It probably does not have a unique spine label either. In book stores, horror may be lost in general fiction or placed with SF/fantasy. Physical access creates problems for readers.

Reviewers and Librarians

Reviewers and librarians often have a negative attitude about horror fiction. Modern horror may contain "serial murder, ritual killings, cannibalism and child abuse" as well as some very explicit sexuality so it may attract negative community reaction too. Few librarians read it and many have stereotypical notions about its quality and value. How much explicit violence and sexuality can be tolerated by readers can be a difficult question. The reader who enjoys mild supernatural stories about ghosts and haunted houses may be wholly uncomfortable with Clive Barker. Demonic possession and Satanism themes may be problematic in some libraries.

Horror fiction issued by small publishers is less likely to be reviewed and noticed outside the specialist reviews.

Small Presses

Smaller specialty publishing houses have found horror to be reasonably popular and profitable. Besides publishing new works and nurturing new authors and tastes, some also reissue the classics in attractive new editions. Small publishers are also likely to issue novellas and short story collections. Night Shade is a good example. Most major publishers do not have a horror imprint.



Discussion Questions

One

What are the differences, if any, in the associations with "horror" versus "dark fantasy?"

Two

Why would readers want to "escape" with a genre that stimulates fear and anxiety as it considers horrible events?

Three

Some critics argue that horror fiction causes readers to think and act in unhealthy, morbid ways. How would you respond? Could this be true of other genres too?

Four

Horror often deals with two subjects that some find very distasteful--explicit sex and explicit violence. Why should the library select such controversial material? What redeeming value might it have? If you do select horror items, any special censorship planning to consider?

Five

Is horror more likely to appeal to male readers, e.g. men like violence while women do not? Why? Is horror an anti-feminist genre since women are often victims?

Six

What relationship, if any, to you see between violence in real life as reported in the mass media and interest in horror fiction? Between horror film and horror books?

Seven

Is horror fiction really more about shock value than telling a good story?


Last major revision: October 2004


Return to 590 Page

Train picture