IS 574: Adult Materials and Services

Readers Advisory

Christian Fiction

logo

Quotes

"We're seeing more books that confront contemporary issues, where Christian faith is tested by the challenges of the real world. The conflict between good and evil isn't new, but writers are handling it in a new way." ~David Troutman

"Christian fiction is growing up. Its stepping out of the Christian ghetto of biblical fiction and romances, and becoming more sophisticated. We're seeing more realism and themes that involve Christians dealing with actual current problems." ~ Jan Dennis

Didacticism isn't preventing these literary novels from effectiveness; craft is the sticking point, and the publishers serving the Christian Booksellers Association (CBA) desperately need capable and experienced fiction editors to bring this genre to m maturity." ~ Susan Wise Bauer

"You can present truth through fiction. People love a good story, and if they can come away from it with a stronger sense of spirituality, the writer has done a good job." ~ Teresa Gayle

"We're trying to create products that are good and artistic, but there's another thing going on that the secular writer doesn't have to deal with--the proclamation of the gospel." ~ Ken Petersen

"...Very few religious novels from Christian publishers achieve the kind of originality, artistry and stylishness that permit them to overcome a probably de riguer didacticism." ~ Michael Dirda

"The simplest story can bring you a new awareness that can eventually be the key to turning your life and heart around. I encourage you to pick up one of these fiction titles. It may change your life!" ~ Sandy Muller

"Once the exclusive domain of headstrong prairie maidens and rogue gunslingers turned righteous hunks, inspirational romance has spun off a few sub genres that are catapulting up the bestseller lists and leaving their formulaic angst behind." ~ Angie Kiesling

"We all tend to cater to the most conservative element of the market because they're the ones we'll hear from." ~ Kevin Bowen

The new African-American Christian fiction "is reaching black people who go to church, but may not have put biblical principles in their lives. CBA readers are already devoted; they are in church, they are tithing. This new breed of Christian fiction is for the person who loves to read, who wants a good story and enjoys reading about how the faith of the characters helps them solve their problems." ~Dudley Delffs

A Few Web Sources

Overbooked (Book Links) has an excellent set of links for Inspirational Fiction. Note their Inspirational Fiction Hot list. A good place to begin.

Christian Booksellers Association has good bestseller information available.

BookBrowser also has a list of series and sequels, reviews of inspirational fiction, and lists of forthcoming titles.

Faithful Reader contains news, reviews, and some author interviews relevant for Christian fiction.

The Fiction_L List of Lists includes book lists for Christian fiction, Christian fiction especially for teens, Oke, Wick and Snelling Readalikes. The Christian Fiction List: Fiction for the Faithful is found here.

A Few Other Sources

Christian Fiction: A Guide to the Genre by John Mort, who is the Booklist reviewer for this genre, is likely to be the standard work.

Developing Christian Fiction Collections for Children & Adults is now the standard work for this genre.

Contemporary Christian Authors: Lives and Works by Janice Delong and Rachel Schwedt cover about 70 Christian fiction authors from a variety of sub genres.

What Inspirational Literature Do I Read Next by Pamela Willwerth includes a substantial section (about 1/3 of the volume) on fiction. Bibliographic entries include similar books.

Now and then, Booklist reviews Christian fiction and lists some series updates.

History

Depending on one's definition of religion, religious stories have been with us since the beginning of time. Pilgrim's Progress in 1678 is a recent example of enormously popular Christian fiction. Grace Livingston Hill published her first light love novel in 1887. The Christian Booksellers Association was not established until 1950. The Gold Medallion Awards, Evangelical Christian Publisher's Association, began in 1978. In 1985, the Romance Writers of American awarded the first RITA for inspirational Fiction. In 1997, Harlequin established its first Christian fiction imprint with Steeple Hill.


Definitions

Christian fiction celebrates God's presence in our life. It can be narrow and didactic or broad and literal. Character's relationship to God is the primary focus. Another definition is that these stories are about "the journey of the soul." Readers seek "wholesome, yet compelling" reading. There is considerable interest in characters "who are like the reader" in some important way.

Although the label "Christian fiction" is used here to reflect the fact that God plays a significant role in the plot and the outcome. Christian novels focus on ordinary people who are challenged to live their lives in accordance with Christian principles.

Inspirational fiction is similar, but would include characters and themes that reflect other religious faiths. This broader view of the genre is increasingly important in communities where there is a notable diversity of faiths. Inspirational fiction recently popular will include those of the Jewish, Buddhist, Hindu and Muslim faiths.

A view book stores use visionary fiction and Borders even uses metaphysical fiction. Neither of these labels are likely to be helpful for the average book buyer or reader. Clearly, the scope and attributes of these works can confuse.

Since the view of Christianity seen in Christian fiction is often from a fundamentalist position,  some readers will avoid works that they might otherwise enjoy [without the label].

Since Christian Fiction does not contain "bad language,", strong violence, addictions, or explicit sexual activity, it can be a genre of gentle reads. The values expressed, putting God first or loving one's neighbor or remaining chaste before marriage, are comfortable ones for many readers, even those who are not especially religious.

While "gentle reads" should probably be a separate category, its characteristics apply to some Christian Fiction, especially earlier ones;

Jan Karon is a well-known contemporary example.

With the possible exception of horror, any genre or sub genre might be part of Christian or inspirational fiction if the appropriate values, world view, and outcomes appear.

Audience

The audience has expanded substantially in recent years as Christian fiction has expanded well beyond the Christian book store to the chain super stores as well as many of the discount stores. The addition of more sub-genres such as suspense and mystery have increased audience. Too, the quality of the story telling and writing has improved substantially in many books. As some stories move from "aggressively evangelical" to a "Christian world view," audience increases. A 2003 study by Barna found that half of all Americans read Christian books and one-third buy them. Some publishers and authors are concerned about the "Christian bubble," the notion that the Christian Bookseller guidelines are so restrictive that the limit content that would be true to Christian principles, but might offend Christian conservatives. For example, is it permissible for a character to drink an alcoholic beverage? The key question here is whether or not the story will bring the reader closer to God.


Awards

CHRISTY AWARDS will be given to novelists and novels of exceptional quality and impact. The first awards were presented in July 2000.Bethany House, Baker Book House, Broadman & Holman, Kregel, Multnomah, Thomas Nelson, Tyndale House, Water Brook, Word, and Zondervan among others support the awards which are affiliated with the Christian Booksellers Association. Christianity Today has provided prize money.

The Evangelical Christian Publishers Association presents the Gold and Platinum Awards. Fiction is one category.

ALLEGORICAL FICTION
Stories representing Biblical truths or stories. May be historical or contemporary. "John Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress (1678) is probably the best example of allegory in all literature. In the surface story a hero named Christian travels toward the Celestial City through a landscape marked by the Slough of Despond, the Valley of the Shadow of Death, and Vanity Fair, and he meets characters such as Faithful and Mr. Worldly Wisdom. The deeper story deals with individual salvation." While many Christian novels have an allegorical element, a few are more allegory than story. Joseph Girzone is a good example.
APOCALYPTIC FICTION
Stories that deal with the end of life as we know it. The focus is on how Christian faith, character, and right behavior in an unbelieving world lead to the promised land. Mass destruction, the rise of the Antichrist, and the times forecast in the book of Revelation are typical elements.
BIBLICAL FICTION
Stories of characters, both real and imagined who lived or might have lived in the New and Old Testament times.
CHRISTIAN CHICK LIT
Stories of independent, strong females willing to forgo traditional roles and discover what God wants them to do with their special talents. Finding the right man may be important, but it is not the main thing.
CHRISTIAN CONTEMPORARY FICTION
Stories set in the time after World War II, usually in the current year or so.
CHRISTIAN FANTASY AND SCIENCE FICTION
Fantasy and science fiction themes and appeal elements set within Christian truths.
CHRISTIAN HISTORICAL FICTION
Stories set in the time before World War II. Particular periods such as the SETTLEMENT OF THE WEST are popular.
CHRISTIAN MYSTERY/SUSPENSE
Suspenseful stories using Christian themes and perspectives. Larry Burkett is a good example.
CHRISTIAN ROMANCE
Romantic stories using Christian themes and perspectives. Janette Oke is a good example. Harlequin's Love Inspired Line does well. Many include romantic suspense and historical romance. Action, suspense and romance are increasingly popular.
CHRISTIAN THRILLERS
Thrilling stories in a variety of genres with considerable action and suspense but with the strong Christian message.
CHRISTIAN WESTERNS
Western or settlement of the West (U.S.) using Christian themes and perspectives. Janette Oke is a good example.
CONTEMPORARY CHRISTIAN ROMANCE
Stories set in the present with current situations and elements.
SUPERNATURAL CHRISTIAN THRILLER
A suspenseful story with thrills and danger involving good versus evil where the Godly will triumph but the challenges are many. Frank Peretti's This Present Darkness was the trend setter while the "Left Behind" stories was an overwhelming success. These stories often appeal to male readers.

Appeal Elements

Appeal elements include:

Redemption

Often, the Christian story makes clear than via God's grace the most troubled souls can find redemption and reconciliation with God. This is a persuasive message, especially for those who are troubled.

Safe, Comfortable Reads

At a time when so much of the popular media is explicit, perhaps unhealthily so, readers want old-fashioned comfortable stories that do not provoke or shock. Series and sequels are increasingly popular and that offers the reader a comfortable read with familiar characters and situations.

Bible Study

Biblical fiction provides insight and understanding into major characters. For the reader, fiction reading becomes educational and spiritual because it helps to understand the word and actions of God.

Trends and Problems

Growing Popularity

There is no question that Christian fiction is popular. The Indwelling: The Beast Takes Possession by Tim LaHaye and Jerry B. Jenkins, in the "Left Behind" series, has sold more than two million copies in the U.S. and is a New York Times bestseller. Much of this appeal appears to come from fundamentalists. Fiction is one of the fastest growing categories in Christian publishing.

Traditionally, Christian fiction has focused on female problems and issues, but male issues and problems are beginning to receive more attention. Strong male characters and novels more likely to appeal to men should broaden the appeal of Christian fiction.

African-American Christian fiction is a small, but rapidly growing trend. Typically, the focus is on contemporary romance, humor, and mystery. Walk Worthy Press was the pioneer in 1997. Some of these titles appeal to African-American readers who would not ordinarily select Christian Fiction.

Crossover

The book trade is much more interested in Christian fiction. Authors such as Frank Peretti, Janette Oke, Bodie Thoene are popular and sell well in trade book stores.

Not Taken Seriously

Until recently, Christian fiction was not taken seriously by many in trade publishing, reviewers, and others. It was "too preachy, too moralistic, too unrealistic or sometimes just too trite." Although the stereotypes are being reduced as Christian fiction becomes more popular and profitable, they are still there.

Most chain bookstores do note give Christian fiction adequate visibility and shelf space.

Too Little Shelf space

While Christian stores and bookstores provide publishers and authors with a highly responsive market, there is too little shelf space to accommodate the growing variety of publications. Publisher websites help, but the enthusiastic reader may find the local Christian book store with limited stock.

Broadening Scope

Publishers of Christian fiction are broadening their lists to include more sub genres including mystery and science fiction. Historical fiction and romances have been popular for some time. Some believe that too much of Christian fiction is historical. Some Christian fiction publishers are hopeful that their work will increasingly be found in the general fiction area (out of the ghetto).

Spiritual Warfare

Some Christian fiction is extremely didactic. "Liberal thought, politics and legal interpretations are inextricably tied to something degenerate, corrupting and ultimately evil." The fight between good and evil is vividly portrayed and much of contemporary civilization is associated with evil.

In much of Christian fiction, "providing moral lessons is considered as more important than creating complex, believable characters."

Other Religions

As religious diversity in the United States increases, it seems reasonable that there will be the equivalent of Christian fiction for other religions. This could cause problems in classification or categorization as well as public relations problems.

Too Comfortable

While the comfortable read is a notable asset, it can also be a liability. Surely, quality fiction should provoke, perhaps even testing the reader. Christian fiction should not be an escape from secular life, but rather a means to understand it and imp rove it.


Discussion Questions

One

How would you respond to the notion that Christian fiction belongs in the church library and not in the public library?

Two

Christian fiction is sometimes called "inspirational" fiction. Does not all genre fiction inspire to some degree?

Three

What do you think of when you hear or see "Christian" as an adjective as in Christian fiction?

Four

If some users react negatively to "Christian fiction" as a label, what would you use instead? Discuss the assets and liabilities of "inspirational," "religious," and "spiritual."

Five

What appeal elements, if any, would be found in Christian fiction and not typically in other genre fiction?

Six

Should Christian fiction be broken out or integrated into the general fiction collection? If broken out, does that indicate favoritism or endorsement of one faith over others? Why?

Seven

How easy would it be to identify and classify books as "Christian" fiction? How would you do it?

Eight

Is Christian fiction just for Christians? Just for women? Just for older readers?

Nine

How didactic or preachy is Christian fiction? Does that decrease the quality of the story? Does not all genre fiction promote values of some kind? How didactic are the other genres?

Ten

If Christian fiction is safe, how safe are the other genres. How would you rank the genres from the most risky to the safest?


Last major revision: August 2005


Return to the 574 Page

Train picture